WithoutBG vs Background Remover: 2026 Comparison

Quick Verdict: WithoutBG is unique: it's open-source (Apache-2.0) with self-hostable models for complete privacy, plus a premium cloud API with p95 latency of just 800ms and EU data residency in Frankfurt. Images are processed in RAM only—no disk writes, no thumbnails, no caches. The Python SDK (pip install withoutbg) makes integration trivial. At €0.05-0.10/credit, it's ideal for privacy-conscious developers and European companies with GDPR requirements. Background Remover at $5/mo offers a ready-to-use web interface without coding. Choose WithoutBG if you're a developer who needs self-hosting, EU compliance, or sub-second API latency. Choose Background Remover if you want simple browser-based background removal without writing code.

---

Our Ratings

Metric	WithoutBG	Background Remover
Overall	⭐ 3.7/5	⭐ 4.6/5
Edge Quality	⭐ 3.7/5	⭐ 4.5/5
Speed	⭐ 4.1/5	⭐ 4.5/5
Value	⭐ 3.8/5	⭐ 4.9/5
Ease of Use	⭐ 4.4/5	⭐ 4.8/5

Quick Comparison

Feature	WithoutBG	Background Remover
Starting Price	$9.99/mo	$5/mo
Free Tier	Yes	Yes
API Access	✅ Yes	❌ No
Mobile App	❌ No	❌ No

Technical Specifications

Specification	WithoutBG	Background Remover
Max File Size	10MB	10MB
Input Formats	JPEG, PNG, WebP, TIFF, BMP, GIF	JPG, PNG, WEBP
Output Format	PNG	PNG
No Account Needed	—	✅ Yes

About WithoutBG

WithoutBG is an open-source background removal tool with both self-hosted and cloud API options. The platform offers a unique dual approach: free open-source models (Focus, Snap) for complete privacy, or a premium cloud API (Model Pro) for highest accuracy. The API runs on AWS Inferentia hardware in Frankfurt, Germany.

Key Features

• Open Source Models - Apache-2.0 licensed, self-host for free
• Premium API - Model Pro with superior edge detection
• Privacy-Focused - No image storage, no training on user data
• Python SDK - Easy integration with pip install
• Docker Support - One-command self-hosted deployment
• Alpha Matte API - Returns grayscale masks for compositing

Security & Privacy

• No disk writes, no thumbnails, no caches stored
• TLS encryption in transit
• Images processed in RAM only, buffers zeroed after processing
• Customer data never used for training
• Hosted in Frankfurt, Germany (EU data residency)

---

Pricing Comparison (Updated February 2026)

WithoutBG Pricing (in €)

Package	Credits	Price	Per Credit	Validity
Free Trial	50	Free	€0.00	30 days
XS	100	€10	€0.10	30 days
S	500	€40	€0.08	30 days
M	1000	€70	€0.07	90 days
L	5000	€300	€0.06	180 days
XL	10000	€500	€0.05	360 days

Open source models are completely free with no credit limit.

Background Remover Pricing

Plan	Price	Credits	Per Image
Starter	$5/mo	50	$0.10
Pro	$20/mo	300	$0.067
Ultra	$50/mo	1000	$0.05

💡 Key Insight: Background Remover offers better value with plans starting at $5/mo for 50 images. Compare pricing carefully based on your monthly volume needs.

---

Choose WithoutBG If:

• ✅ You're a developer who wants to self-host background removal for complete data control: WithoutBG's open-source models (Apache-2.0) can be deployed via Docker on your own infrastructure—your images never leave your servers.
• ✅ Your company has strict GDPR compliance or EU data residency requirements: WithoutBG's cloud API runs exclusively in Frankfurt, Germany, with no image storage, no disk writes, and RAM-only processing for maximum privacy.
• ✅ You need sub-second API latency for real-time applications: With p95 latency of ~800ms server-side, WithoutBG is built for interactive use cases where users are waiting for immediate results.
• ✅ You want both free open-source AND premium commercial options: Use the free Focus/Snap models for development and testing, then upgrade to Model Pro for production when you need the highest quality.
• ✅ You're a Python developer who wants dead-simple integration: pip install withoutbg and you're running—the SDK handles authentication, retries, and error handling automatically.

Choose Background Remover If:

• ✅ You're a marketer, designer, or business user who needs background removal without coding: No Python knowledge required, no terminal commands, no Docker containers—just upload images in your browser and download results.
• ✅ You want to see and approve results before they're finalized: Background Remover shows you exactly what the output looks like in real-time. API responses show you JSON—you need to write code to see the actual image.
• ✅ You prefer a simple web interface over managing API keys and credit packages: Background Remover is a subscription—sign up, use it, done. No tracking credit balances or validity periods.
• ✅ You process 50-300 images monthly and want predictable monthly pricing: At $5/mo-$20/mo with no per-image surprises, you always know what you'll pay. WithoutBG's credit packages require calculating usage upfront.
• ✅ You don't want to evaluate open-source vs commercial models or deployment options: Background Remover gives you one solution that works—no decisions about self-hosting, model selection, or infrastructure.

---

Pros & Cons

WithoutBG

Pros:

• API available
• Batch processing
• Simple interface
• Decent quality

Cons:

• Limited free tier
• Average quality
• Less established
• Pricing comparable

Background Remover

Pros:

• Best price-per-image value ($0.05-0.10)
• Clean, modern interface
• Fast processing (5 seconds)
• Reliable batch processing
• Straightforward pricing

Cons:

• No mobile app yet
• No API access
• Desktop-focused workflow

---

FAQ

Is WithoutBG free?

WithoutBG offers 3 free images. Paid plans start at $9.99/month.

Does WithoutBG have an API?

Yes, WithoutBG offers API access for developers.

---

Related Comparisons

• Remove.bg vs Background Remover
• PhotoRoom vs Background Remover
• Canva vs Background Remover
• Adobe Express vs Background Remover
• Erase.bg vs Background Remover

---

Try Background Remover Today

Ready for quality background removal with great value?

Start removing backgrounds now →

Starter plan: 50 images for just $5/month. No commitment, cancel anytime.